Module 2

Portfolio margin & the scenario grid

Portfolio margin is the OCC's risk-based approach — its engine is called TIMS (Theoretical Intermarket Margining System) — and it is the conceptual ancestor of every risk-based system that followed.

The mechanics:

  • Group positions into class groups (same underlying) and product groups (correlated underlyings).
  • For each class group, build a scenario grid: shock spot across a range — ±15% for typical equities, ±20% or more for high-vol names, tighter for broad indices — at ten equally spaced points, and shock implied vol up and down at each point.
  • Fully reprice every position at every node.The class group's requirement is the worst-case loss across the grid.
  • Apply offsets between class groups at prescribed percentages — 90% within a highly correlated product group, less across groups — then sum, with a minimum per position.

The key conceptual point: the hedge benefit is automatic, because you reprice the whole portfolio at each node rather than netting requirements computed separately. A long stock / long put position shows a small worst-case loss because the put gains where the stock loses in the same scenario. This is the same reason netting sets matter in counterparty credit risk — you compute the measure on the aggregate, not aggregate the measure (see the PFE module).

🎛 Interactive scenario grid

Build a position, then read the grid like the clearing house does

100
-1
0
15%
vol \ spot-15%-12%-9%-6%-3%0%+3%+6%+9%+12%+15%
vol ↑-1.4k-1.1k-0.8k-0.5k-0.3k-0.1k0.1k0.2k0.3k0.4k0.5k
base-1.3k-1k-0.8k-0.5k-0.2k0k0.2k0.3k0.5k0.5k0.6k
vol ↓-1.3k-1k-0.7k-0.4k-0.2k0.1k0.3k0.5k0.6k0.6k0.6k

Margin requirement — worst cell on the grid

$1,357

worst-case P&L: -$1,357 (outlined cell)

This is the OCC/TIMS idea in miniature: shock spot across the scan range at equally spaced points, shock implied vol up and down at each, fully reprice every position at every node, and charge the worst-case loss. Try long stock + short calls (covered call) versus naked short calls — repricing the aggregate is what makes the hedge benefit automatic. Educational tool — not investment advice.

Things to try

  • Covered call: +100 shares, −1 call. The worst cell sits on the downside — the short call only softens it.
  • Naked short calls: 0 shares, −3 calls. The worst cell jumps to the top-right corner: spot up, vol up. The vol dimension exists precisely for this.
  • Collar: +100 shares, −1 call, +1 put. Watch the requirement collapse — every scenario is bounded.
  • • Widen the scan range from 15% to 30% (a high-vol single name) and watch the same portfolio get charged more.

Test yourself

A client is long 100 shares and long 1 deep-ITM put. Under Reg T the put adds to the requirement; under portfolio margin the combination is nearly riskless. Which number better reflects the loss the broker would actually face on default — and what does the answer imply about who should be allowed portfolio margin?