Punch a $25,000 account and a 45-day lock-up into the [Income Planner](/options/planner) with the default settings — no leverage, normal liquidity, a 4.0%-a-year floor, ranked by probability of profit, reward for risk and liquidity together — and the machine does something refreshingly blunt. It screens the full option universe (chains sourced from CBOE), finds 92 trades that qualify, and throws out the rest with a reason attached. Here's what survived, and what the rejects say about the trades that only look good on a screen.
The top of the board
#1 is a TLT put credit spread (0.25/0.10 delta, expiring 2026-12-18): 3 contracts, $747 of capital, $153 premium, probability of profit 73.7%. The reason it ranks first isn't a monster payout — reward/risk after costs is a modest 0.2 — it's the package. Liquidity is pristine (min open interest 43,096, round-trip cost just 3.9% of the premium), and the probability is respectable. Best case is 20.48% on the cash tied up, though only 0.61% on all the capital because the trade is small. The catch: max loss and stress loss are both -$747. A spread this tight has no cushion — a two-standard-deviation move (roughly 1 time in 40 at today's implied vol) takes the whole thing.
#2 is a further-out TLT spread (0.15/0.05 delta): probability jumps to 87.5%, but you're paid for it with less — $60 premium on $540 capital, reward/risk 0.105, round trip eating 10.0% of the premium. This is the Planner's rules writ large: higher probabilities come with smaller gains and the same occasional full loss (stress loss -$540).
#3, an IWM iron condor (0.16/0.05 delta), is the first trade where stress testing actually separates headline risk from real risk. Max loss reads -$2,618, but the stress loss is -$1,175 — the two-sided structure caps the damage. Probability of profit 75.9%, premium $282, open interest 1,161. That's the kind of structural detail you won't see on a chain screen but will see in [Desk Strategies](/options/desk-strategies).
Where size quietly dominates the math
Notice how far on-capital returns drift from on-cash returns down the list. The #4 IWM cash-secured put has a gorgeous 91.6% probability of profit and a stress loss of only -$1,122, but it ties up $24,564 for a $236 premium — best case 0.96% on cash, and reward/risk a rounding-error 0.009. High probability, almost no reward. The #5 SLV cash-secured put is similar: 85.9% probability, $405 premium, $24,195 capital, but the stress loss balloons to -$2,746 because silver moves.
Then there's #7, the SLV covered call (0.30 delta): the fattest premium on the board at $575 and the best on-capital number here — 10.54% on all the capital. But probability of profit is only 55.4%, and the stress loss is a stomach-churning -$4,994. That's the trade-off the Planner is scoring for you: the covered call pays the most and loses the most, which is exactly why it ranks seventh and not first.
The efficient tail
Capital-light trades keep the reward/risk honest. #9, an IEF put credit spread, posts the best reward/risk on the list at 0.242 and best case 25.79% on the cash tied up — on $318 of capital and $82 premium, with deep liquidity (open interest 18,687). #10, a weekly SLV spread expiring 2026-11-13, shows 80.8% probability and reward/risk 0.17, but round trip costs 15.9% of the premium — close to the strict-liquidity line.
What the exclusions are telling you
The rejects are the real lesson. The Planner left out: `spread_eats_premium`: 126, `capital_too_small`: 150, `illiquid`: 107, `lock_too_short`: 93, and `below_min_income`: 3. The two biggest buckets — bid-ask eating the premium (126) and trades the account can't afford (150) — are exactly the ones that look fine until you cross four legs twice. Spreads pay the bid-ask on every leg, to open and to close or roll; a thin chain quietly hands your premium to the market maker. The 107 `illiquid` rejections never had a prayer under normal liquidity (40% round trip, 100+ open interest). Only 3 trades failed purely on income — the screen is far more worried about cost and fit than yield.
Remember these probabilities are risk-neutral, not forecasts — a setup, not a signal. Indicative quotes can be wider than the live market, and "repeat the trade" assumes prices that won't hold.
Next step: open the [Income Planner](/options/planner), enter your own balance and lock-up, then pull any name above into its [Options Playbook](/options/playbook/TLT) and check the Heston mispricing page at [/options/playbook/TLT/model](/options/playbook/TLT/model) before you touch a chain.