Income ideas on diversified ETFs
Earn income from options on 23 liquid ETFs: pick how you want to earn it and how much swing you can stand, and see what a month pays next to what a bad month costs. Priced live; open any 2 ETFs in detail free (SPY always).
Rent out ETFs I own: 0 ETFs
Pricing 23 ETF option chains…
What the evidence says
Cboe's S&P 500 put-writing index (PUT), selling cash-secured puts every month since 1986, returned 9.4% a year against 9.9%for the S&P 500 through August 2023, with volatility of 10.3% against 15.4% and a worst drop of about −33% against −51%. Selling options on an index has earned stock-like returns with smaller swings: a smoother ride, not extra return. You give up the best rallies and keep most of the crash risk.
Income funds are judged on total return, not yield: a high headline yield can come with weaker total return than the index in rising markets. Across other periods the record is mixed (2006-2015 PUT trailed, 6.6% against 7.1% a year), and costs matter: our own research found the edge shrinks fast once you pay the bid-ask spread.
Sources: Cboe, cash-secured put writing (2023), Cboe options-selling indexes study (2016), Morningstar on covered-call funds, Driessen, Maenhout & Vilkov (2009). Educational analysis only; nothing here places orders.
Choosing an ETF and a strike
- Where the income comes from
- Option buyers pay for insurance and for leverage. On broad indexes they pay more than the moves that follow, on average: implied vol runs above realised vol (the variance risk premium). An income strategy sells that insurance, so its return is the premium minus the moves you end up paying for.
- Nothing is free
- A covered call caps the upside, a cash-secured put takes the downside at its strike, spreads trade a smaller premium for a fixed worst case. A covered call and a cash-secured put at the same strike have the same payoff; they differ only in what you hold.
- Why diversified ETFs
- The premium is largest and steadiest on indexes: investors pay up for crash protection, and index options are dearer than single-stock options because stocks fall together in a crash. A broad ETF also spreads the risk of the shares you may end up owning, and its options are the most liquid.
- Broad index first
- SPY, QQQ, IWM and DIA have the deepest option markets and the best-documented premium. Sector and single-country ETFs pay more because they move more, and you take that concentrated risk if you are assigned or called away.
- Delta is the odds
- A 0.30-delta option has roughly a 30% chance of finishing in the money. Selling 0.15-0.20 delta pays less and is exercised less often; 0.40-0.50 pays more but caps or assigns far more often. Monthly expiries 30-45 days out collect time decay at its fastest without weekly management.
- Sell when premium is rich
- Implied vol well above the ETF's recent realised vol (1.2x or more in the table) means you are paid more than recent moves justify. When it is below realised, premium sellers are paid less than the risk they take: smaller size, or wait.
- Bonds and commodities differ
- Bond ETFs move little, so their option income is small and their dividends do most of the work. Commodity ETFs (USO especially) pay large premiums because they move a lot and can gap on supply news; size them smaller.
- Dividends, early assignment
- A covered call in the money just before the ETF goes ex-dividend may be exercised early by a buyer who wants the dividend. Check ex-dividend dates; rolling the call out before them avoids most of it.
- Manage, don't predict
- Common rules: take profits at about half the maximum credit, roll a tested short option out in time for a credit rather than taking assignment you don't want, and keep any one ETF's assignment risk a modest share of the account.
