Income ideas on stocks
Covered calls, cash-secured puts and put spreads on about 500 stocks the big investors hold, priced once a trading day. Single stocks pay more than ETFs because they move more and gap on earnings: compare the income with the bad month before you pick.
Rent out stocks I own: 0 stocks
Loading today's scan…
What the evidence says
Cboe's S&P 500 put-writing index (PUT), selling cash-secured puts every month since 1986, returned 9.4% a year against 9.9%for the S&P 500 through August 2023, with volatility of 10.3% against 15.4% and a worst drop of about −33% against −51%. Selling options on an index has earned stock-like returns with smaller swings: a smoother ride, not extra return. You give up the best rallies and keep most of the crash risk.
Income funds are judged on total return, not yield: a high headline yield can come with weaker total return than the index in rising markets. Across other periods the record is mixed (2006-2015 PUT trailed, 6.6% against 7.1% a year), and costs matter: our own research found the edge shrinks fast once you pay the bid-ask spread.
Sources: Cboe, cash-secured put writing (2023), Cboe options-selling indexes study (2016), Morningstar on covered-call funds, Driessen, Maenhout & Vilkov (2009). Educational analysis only; nothing here places orders.
Choosing a stock and a strike
- Where the income comes from
- Option buyers pay for insurance and for leverage. On broad indexes they pay more than the moves that follow, on average: implied vol runs above realised vol (the variance risk premium). An income strategy sells that insurance, so its return is the premium minus the moves you end up paying for.
- Nothing is free
- A covered call caps the upside, a cash-secured put takes the downside at its strike, spreads trade a smaller premium for a fixed worst case. A covered call and a cash-secured put at the same strike have the same payoff; they differ only in what you hold.
- Earnings come first
- A single stock can gap 5-15% on earnings or news, more than a month of premium. Most option sellers avoid expiries that span the next earnings date, or size smaller when they don't. Check the date before you sell.
- Only stocks you'd own
- A cash-secured put can leave you holding the shares after bad news, and a covered call can lose you the shares just before good news. Sell options only on companies you would be content to own at the strike.
- Concentration
- One stock is far riskier than an index: keep any single name's assignment risk a small share of the account, and spread across sectors.
- High premium means high risk
- The stocks paying 40-60% a year are the ones the market expects to move most. Compare the income with the bad-month column, not with an ETF's yield.
- Liquidity
- Many stocks' options trade thinly: a wide bid-ask spread can eat a large part of the premium. Prefer "good" trading and use limit orders at or near the mid.
- Manage, don't predict
- Common rules: take profits at about half the maximum credit, roll a tested short option out in time for a credit rather than taking assignment you don't want.
