Research/Options
OptionsFriday, November 6, 2026

The Week in Vol: Where the Gap Sat, What the Shadow Book Held

A walk through this week's CBOE volatility index closes, the gap between index vol and ATM straddle IV, and how RetailVest's shadow book sat heading into December expiry. Implied stayed above realised across every SPY session we checked.

Another week, another spread between what the vol indices advertise and what the options chains actually pay. Here's the RetailVest read on where things sat as of Friday, November 6, 2026, built entirely from CBOE data (via FRED), our Options Desk captures, and the shadow book. No predictions — just what the numbers showed and what you can check next.

The CBOE indices: energy and silver run hot

Using CBOE's 30-day implied-vol index closes from FRED (as of 2026-11-05), the dispersion across asset classes was wide. Oil led the pack with OVXCLS (USO) at 60.10 vol points, followed by silver's VXSLVCLS (SLV) at 46.82. Emerging markets ran warm too — VXEEMCLS (EEM) printed 37.42 and QQQ's VXNCLS sat at 36.98, with EWZ (VXEWZCLS) at 35.61.

At the calmer end, broad US equity was comparatively sleepy: VIXCLS (SPY) closed 26.01, its 3-month cousin VXVCLS at 24.34, and DIA's VXDCLS at 21.68. Small caps (RVXCLS) sat at 27.57 and gold (GVZCLS) at 25.86. One housekeeping note: the FXE euro vol series (EVZCLS) has been discontinued, last printing 2025-03-11, so treat any FXE position as running without a live index reference.

Where the gap sat

The more interesting number for premium sellers isn't the index itself — it's the gap between the index and the at-the-money straddle IV the desk can actually transact. From our Options Desk 15:30 ET capture (as of 2026-11-04), the index sat *above* ATM IV across the board, so the index minus a haircut is roughly the vol the desk effectively sells.

Silver showed the widest gap: SLV index 45.98 vs ATM straddle IV 39.74, a +6.24 point spread, with the December 4 straddle at $4.28 — a chunky 9.05% of the $47.30 spot. USO's gap ran +4.88 (58.81 vs 53.93), and that straddle was 12.34% of spot — the fattest premium on the sheet at $17.90 against a $145.10 spot. EEM and EWZ carried gaps of +4.08 and +3.92 respectively.

The mega-cap names were tighter. SPY's gap was +3.22 (index 16.61 vs ATM IV 13.39), with the K=768 straddle at $23.79, or 3.10% of the $768.17 spot. DIA and IWM both showed +2.54 point gaps. You can pull all of this yourself on Chains & Gap (/options/chains).

Implied vs realised: the setup, not a signal

Over the trailing 90 days (as of 2026-11-06), implied stayed stubbornly above realised. For SPY (VIXCLS), the index averaged 16.3 against a 21-day realised average of 10.8 — a +5.6 point spread, and the index sat above realised in 100% of 63 sessions. IWM (RVXCLS) was similar: 20.4 vs 13.7, a +6.7 spread, also 100% of sessions. USO's spread was the widest at +7.3 (52.3 vs 45.0) but less consistent, clearing realised 75% of the time.

QQQ (VXNCLS) ran 22.9 vs 18.0 (+4.9, 79% of sessions), and gold (GVZCLS) was the thinnest edge: 24.7 vs 23.7, a mere +1.0 point spread, above realised just 67% of sessions. Our longer SPY detail window tells the same story — index avg 16.5 vs realised 11.32 over 85 sessions, above realised 98.8% of the time.

Say it plainly: implied above realised is a *setup*, not a signal. The spread is raw premium before the ATM discount (the gap above) and before costs. Test it before you believe it.

What the shadow book did

The ETF options shadow book (as of 2026-11-04) was in Mode shadow — no live orders — with capital marked at $256,870, cumulative P&L of $0.00 over one day, and zero drawdown. Open positions were all short straddles hitting targets exactly: DIA -1 (K=534), EEM -12 (K=61.5), EWZ -19 (K=32.0), GLD -2 (K=373), IWM -2 (K=284), SLV -10 (K=47.5), SPY -1 (K=768), and USO -5 (K=145), all December 4 expiry. The lone November 20 line is FXE -50 (K=104) — the position running without a live index since EVZCLS went dark.

What to watch next week

Two things stand out. First, whether USO's 60.10 index and 12.34%-of-spot straddle keep that premium or mean-revert — oil's spread was wide but inconsistent. Second, whether SPY's near-perfect streak of implied over realised holds; a single vol spike flips that math fast.

Want to pressure-test any of it? Run the SLV or USO short straddle through the Options Backtester (/options/backtest), dig into the spread history on Options Research (/options/research), or ask Tara the AI analyst to walk you through why the index sits above ATM IV. New to the mechanics? Start with the ETF Options tutorial (/tutorials/etf-options), then open the Options Desk (/options) and compare today's gap to the +6.24 we logged on silver.

#volatility#ETF options#straddles

Market data for informational purposes only. Not financial advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

How are we doing?