Module 7 of 12 · Selling premium

Covered calls and cash-secured puts

A covered call is a long ETF position with a call sold against it. You collect the premium; if the ETF rallies past the strike your shares are called away at the strike and you keep the premium but not the rally. A cash-secured put is the mirror: hold cash, sell a put below the market, and if the ETF falls through the strike you buy the shares there. By put-call parity the two have the same payoff; they differ in margin, in dividends and in how they feel.

Both are premium selling with a built-in hedge, which is why brokers allow them in ordinary accounts. The covered call still owns the ETF's crashes in full; the premium softens them by a percent or two. What it gives up is the right tail: the months when the market gaps up and the call seller is left behind.

The lab compares each strategy with simply holding the ETF, on a synthetic fund with zero drift so the comparison isolates what the option does. It reports volatility, skew, drawdown and the share of cycles in which the option finished in the money.

🎛 Covered call lab

3%
3 pts
21

Sharpe, strategy

-0.08

Sharpe, ETF alone

-0.17

Premium collected / yr

18.7%

of ETF value

Cycles called away

26%

Vol, strategy

17.3%

Vol, ETF alone

24.5%

Skew, strategy

-0.93

Max drawdown, strategy

101.0%

Synthetic ETF with zero drift, so any difference between the two lines comes from the option, not from the market going up. Covered call: own the ETF, sell a 30-day call the chosen distance above spot, repeat. Cash-secured put: hold cash, sell a 30-day put the chosen distance below spot, repeat; the comparison line is still the ETF itself. Both pay 2% of premium as bid-ask. The call version keeps the ETF's crashes and gives away its rallies; the put version has the same payoff shape with a different margin treatment.

Selling calls lowers volatility and worsens skew

With the strike 3% above spot and a 3-point premium, the covered call shows a higher Sharpe ratio than the ETF, lower volatility, and a more negative skew. All three follow from the same cut: the option removes the best months and leaves the worst ones. The premium pays for that over time, but it pays in small steady amounts, and the cost arrives in the months you would most have liked to be fully invested.

Move the strike to 10% above spot. The premium shrinks to almost nothing, the strategy is almost the ETF, and the Sharpe ratio difference disappears. Move it to the money and the strategy becomes a short straddle in disguise: income every month, and the full downside. The strike is the dial between owning the market and selling volatility.

Things to try

  • • Set the premium to 0 and confirm the covered call no longer beats the ETF on Sharpe: without a premium it is just a capped position paying bid-ask.
  • • Switch to the cash-secured put at the same distance and compare: same shape, same income, different margin.
  • • Raise the strike until fewer than 10% of cycles are called away and note what happens to the premium collected.

Original interactive lesson. Labs run on a seeded synthetic ETF in your browser, built to illustrate mechanics, not to predict any real market. Option prices use a textbook model with zero interest rates. Educational analysis, not investment advice.

How are we doing?