Module 9 of 12 · Running it for real
Skew, and why the vol index is not your price
Implied volatility is not one number per expiry. Plot it by strike and you get a curve: on equity ETFs, puts below the market trade at higher implied vol than calls above it, and the far wings are richer still. That is skew, and it is the market charging more for crash protection than for rally participation.
A published 30-day vol index is built from the whole curve: it is a weighted average of out-of-the-money option variances across strikes, with the weighting tilted toward the puts. So the index is not the implied vol of any option you can sell. It is the strike of a variance swap, which retail accounts cannot trade, and it sits above the at-the-money vol by the skew premium. On the S&P 500 that gap has typically been one to three points, and wider in frightened markets.
This is the single most important number in the research behind this track. Simulated on real index histories, selling at-the-money straddles at the index vol produced a Sharpe ratio near 2; selling them at the index minus 2 points produced close to zero. The free data contain the index; they do not contain the gap. The lab lets you see why.
🎛 Skew lab
Vol index implied by the smile
36.0%
Index − ATM gap
18.0 pts
what the index overstates
5% OTM put price
0.90
vs 0.42 at ATM vol
Put skew premium
+113%
richer than flat vol
Sharpe, sold at the index
0.23
not tradeable
Sharpe, sold at ATM
-4.46
what you can trade
Worst cycle at ATM
-353.3%
Return / yr at ATM
-704.2%
Left tiles: a strike-by-strike implied vol (the smile) built from three sliders, the variance-swap-style index it implies using the published strike-weighting method, and the gap between that index and the at-the-money vol. Right tiles: the hedged straddle strategy from Module 6 on the synthetic ETF, sold at the index level versus sold at the index minus that gap. The index is not a price you can trade; the straddle is. On real ETFs the gap moves with the skew and is largest when markets are frightened, which is exactly when the index looks most tempting.
The research result lives inside the gap
Set the at-the-money vol to 18, the put skew to 1.2 and the curvature to 0.08, which is a normal-looking equity smile. The index implied by that smile is about 20: a 2-point gap. Now look at the right-hand tiles. Sold at the index level the synthetic strategy earns comfortably; sold at the true at-the-money vol, 2 points lower, its Sharpe ratio drops by more than half. Nothing about the market changed; only the price you actually get.
The honest way to know the gap is to measure it: capture the at-the-money straddle's implied vol every afternoon alongside the index close, for every ETF, and build the history that the public data lack. That capture is running on this site's paper account; until it has months of data, the strategy's expected return is a range, not a number.
Things to try
- • Set the put skew to 0 and curvature to 0: the index equals ATM vol and both Sharpe ratios match.
- • Raise the skew to 2.5, as on a frightened day: the gap doubles and the tradeable Sharpe goes negative.
- • Note the 5%-out put's price in the smile versus at flat vol: that extra is what put buyers pay, and what a put seller, not a straddle seller, collects.
Original interactive lesson. Labs run on a seeded synthetic ETF in your browser, built to illustrate mechanics, not to predict any real market. Option prices use a textbook model with zero interest rates. Educational analysis, not investment advice.