Tools · Options
SPX box spread calculator
What is a box spread?
A box spread is four options at two strikes and one expiry that together pay a fixed amount, the distance between the strikes, whatever the index does. Selling a box brings in cash today and commits you to pay that fixed amount at expiry, so it works as a loan, and the gap between the two is the interest. On SPX the rate has usually been close to the Treasury yield for the same term, well below most brokers' margin rates.
Boxes to sell
1
4 option contracts in all
Cash received today
$95,598
956.02 points per box, after $4 in fees
Paid back at expiry
$100,000
$100,000 per box, fixed
Interest cost
$4,402
4.60% a year, fees included
Same loan on margin
$6,501
at 6.80% a year
Saved with the box
$2,099
before tax, if held to expiry
The order: sell the call and buy the put at the lower strike, buy the call and sell the put at the higher strike, same expiry, as one four-leg order with a limit of 956.02 points credit. Arithmetic only: these are not quotes, and the rate you get is whatever the market fills.
How selling a box becomes a loan
Take strikes 5,000 and 6,000 on SPX, one year out. You sell the 5,000 call and buy the 5,000 put, and you buy the 6,000 call and sell the 6,000 put. At expiry the four options always net to 1,000 index points against you, which is $100,000 per box, wherever the index finishes. If the market pays you 955 points ($95,500) for the box today, you have borrowed $95,500 and will repay $100,000: about 4.7% for the year.
Why SPX, and not SPY or a stock
- European exercise. SPX options can be exercised only at expiry. Options on SPY or on a stock can be exercised early, which breaks the box and can leave a large unhedged position overnight.
- Cash settlement. SPX settles in cash, so no shares change hands at expiry.
- Depth. SPX is the most heavily traded index option, and institutions quote boxes in it, so fills near the fair rate are realistic for standard sizes.
What can go wrong
- It uses margin. The broker holds margin against the box and marks it to market daily. The borrowed cash is not free buying power: if the rest of the account falls, the box does not protect it and a margin call can force sales at a bad time.
- Account type matters. Under standard (Reg T) margin a short box can tie up close to its full value, which removes most of the point. The trade is normally done in a portfolio-margin account.
- The rate is fixed only if you hold to expiry. Closing early means buying the box back at the market rate of that day, which can cost more than you saved.
- Execution. It must be sent as one four-leg order with a limit price. Legging in, or using a market order, can lose more than a year of interest in one fill.
- Tax is different from a loan. In the US, SPX options fall under Section 1256: the cost shows up as a capital loss, split 60% long-term and 40% short-term and marked at year-end, not as deductible interest. How that works out depends on your own situation.
- Never with American-style options. The well-known retail blow-ups with boxes came from early assignment on stock options.
How to read the calculator
Enter the amount, the days to the expiry you would use and the distance between the strikes. The calculator gives the number of boxes, the cash you would receive at the rate you typed, what you repay and the all-in rate after fees. If a broker shows you a real credit for the box, type it in the last field to see the rate that quote implies. The comparison with a margin loan uses the rate you enter for your own broker.
This page is education and arithmetic. It does not use live quotes and is not a recommendation to borrow or to trade options. Selling options requires broker approval and can lose money; check the margin treatment and the tax treatment with your broker and a tax adviser first.
Related: options basics · portfolio margin · Reg T vs risk-based margin · all tools